Minglewood: Starts same as 5/8/77, always a good sign. Nice sounding tape so far, Keith very prominent. Keith solo, always an underrated portion of this song. Brent was a much different player and soloist. Keith is much more subtle, but during a Keith solo, it always pays off to listen to Jerry’s “rhythm” playing in support. This is something that he does very uniquely and in my opinion better than anyone else. It is very prominent in JGB shows. Overall, a nice hot ’77 Minglewood opener.
Sugaree: The Tapers Compendium reviewer claims this to be his favorite Sugaree ever. (BTW, if you do not have the compendiums, they are an absolute MUST have) This tape continues to be a good mix, with each member being clearly heard. An interesting thing about the Grateful Dead is each members actual influence and importance to every song. For instance, this is the 175th time they have played Sugaree, but each member is doing something unique each and every time. I can absolutely see how someone would think this is the best version ever, all 17 minutes of it. Jerry’s solos are very liquid and tactful, his voice very personable and human. Donna always adds a nice flavor to the ’77 versions of this song. 6:15 into the song, Keith starts his solo. Jerry begins to intertwine his own solo on top of Keith’s for a very full sound. Bobby’s guitar work during this part is exquisite, with his downbeat strums adding a layer both on top of and inside of the music. The drummers follow Garcia and pick up the excitement for the end of the solo break, complete with Jerry’s patented chord strum solo. Truly one of the best versions of this song ever.
Mexicali Blues: Jerry starts out this song sounding like the trumpets on the album version of this song. This song always sounds pretty ridiculous with two drummers, but they seem to hold it together. Short sweet version, nothing special.
Row Jimmy: Keith whips out the funky electric keyboard for this tune. I am not the biggest fan of this song, especially in the 70’s. I think this song grew its hair in the late 80’s and 90’s, with Jerry’s more full guitar tone, although Donna, again, is nice to have on this song. I think the slide Jerry always plays in this song is a little unnecessary.
Passenger – YES! Love me some ’77 passengers. I find it hilarious that Phil wrote this song. One of the highest energy songs in the Grateful Dead song book. Another positive Donna experience, am I becoming a true fan of Donna? Perhaps…Jerry, keeps the slide out, and tears it up with some lead fills and aosm rhythm playing. The drummers are pure force in this song, and Weir’s strong vocals lead this quick hitter.
Sunrise – Just when I was so positive about Donna…I may have spoken too soon. This song is OK, at best, although I’m sure the fans were a little put off by it after a rockin’ passenger. I can’t help but laugh thinking about the gehs playing this one in the Cig Years with Brent on lead vocals. Ok, thank god that is over.
Brown Eyed Women – One of Jerry’s best songs starts off with the fans clapping in anticipation. My favorite part of this song is Weir’s playing. He does so much on top of the lyrics in this song. ’77 is the best year for this song in my opinion, and this version does not disappoint.
It’s All Over Now – Bobby truly has a huge bonedogger for this jam in 1977. Love Garcia’s arpeggio playing in this song. This song can be a little sloppy with the drummers being a little too aggressive. This version is no different. Bobby is extremely excited and screams the lyrics more than he sings them.
Jack-A-Roe – This song changed very much after this era. It started as a funky song, complete with Weir disco style licks, a la Dancin’ in the Streets.
Lazy Lightnin’ – Jingle Bells themed with billy and mickey riding their bells hard. Always appreciate Donna in this song. Lately, I have been extremely pro-Donna, and it is scaring me sometimes. A tragedy that the gentlemen stopped playing this song. Although, it could be a blessing in disguise as it is almost frightening to think about a 90’s version of this tune. Bobby’s mucous screams lead into…
Supplication – Garcia starts by dancing around with his typical ’77 tone. I just love the balance of keith and bobby being the “rhythm players”. I feel like it is something that Bobby and Brent never really worked out. Drummers are excited and hitting cowbells and toms galore. Jerry continues with some serious chord soloing, with phil doing his ’77 slide up “doo doo doo doo”. About 4 minutes in, Bobby finally starts singing with one of the funniest lines in GD history: “Dizzy Ain’t the word for the way you’re making me feel now”. I think supplication would be quite an experience to see live, it is one of the fastest, deepest grooves the GD had in their song book, and much like it’s sister song above, could be a blessing they stopped playing it. (Although they did play it a few times as a stand alone jam, and I think Bobby even sang it a couple times)
Bertha- Beginning of my tape is cut off a little bit, but the boys tear into a typical ’77 rockin’ Bertha. Jerry’s mic doesn’t pick up the first verse too well, but all is well after that. Listening to Phil in a Bertha gives someone a perfect example about how different they play the same song each time. Phil consistently does something different in every version of this song. In this particular version, he is all over the upper frets of his bass. Always the same style, never the same way. After a LOT of “anymooooore”ing, the boys groove right into
Good Lovin’ – Love the pre-shakedown street album start to this song. Bobby tells the boys “easy” around the 45 second mark, to which no one seems to listen. Seems to be a frequent happening for suggestions made by Mr. Weir. Jerry works up the neck during his first solo, and brilliantly takes the solo to another level an octave higher with the traditional Good Lovin’ lick made famous by the rascals. I literally laughed out loud when bobby suggests good love is necessary “even in Russia”. Ahhhh, pre cold war hilarity
Ramble on Rose – Wonderful. Love bobby’s tactful additions behind jerry’s angelic voice on this. Again, Donna is absolutely appreciated on this number. I am beginning to question why people don’t like her. Jerry’s solo is nice, but wish he turned on his MUTRON III. I forget when he started doing this, but it was a definite plus. It makes the solos he doesn’t use it sound hollow. This version is a little below average for the time period. The drummers get a little too aggressive, during the final verse build up. But I am just trying to be picky…
Estimated Prophet – Now we are talking. To be fair, this is my favorite grateful dead song. And I was happy to see in a interview with Jerry that this is his favorite Bobby song. (His least favorite: Minglewood). The tape starts with an Aud patch that quickly returns to the SBD. MUTRON is out in full force here. I admit that my heart skips a beat every single time “You all been asleep” part begins, because that part through the solo is my favorite part of any Grateful Dead song. Keith’s weird sounding synth/organ takes them into Garcia solo. Disappointingly short. Something to remember about ’77 Estimated Prophets is that the main solo is also very short. It really extends in the late 80’s and 90’s. On the other hand, the “NAH NAH NAH NAH NAH-NAH OOOOOOO” jam is extended and glorious. Drummers perfectly in the pocket, bobby and keith playing the extremely difficult rhythm part, Lesh driving a melodic base line, and Garcia playing in a way only he could do. This is a great estimated, but there are certainly better one’s to be found in ’77 and outside of ’77. Heavy drums lead into the song so often paired with Estimated.
Eyes of the World- Garcia starts with a very harsh tone, before dancing a melody on the high strings. A long intro solo (3:55) at a pretty quick pace guides them into the first verse. ’77 is an excellent year for pretty much every tune, but this is especially true for Eyes of the World. Their sound forms itself right around this song. Jerry seems to be taking a lot of chances on his solos in both the intro and solo 1. To be honest, most of them don’t work out that well. However, as I type this, he brings it together for several spectacular runs right in a row. Bobby hilariously is completely out of tune on the second chorus.
The Other One: Phil starts it off with a bomb, and drummers are very heavy in the mix. Garcia plays a dissonant solo with bobby twinkling rhythms behind him, while Phil drives a bassline into the first verse. The first solo comprises of scale runs leading into a free jam, where Garcia is clearly the leader. The drummers are mixed very well in this recording, each of them prevalent and clear. The jam silks back into The Other One theme, but then fades away with Keith and Jerry giving heavy Wharf Rat teases, finally everyone drops out except Garcia, and a spacey jam evolves into Wharf Rat.
Wharf Rat- Begins bold and strong. I love Weir in this tune, as he is always adding tactful rhythm lines that only he can do. Keith is prominent in the mix, and during the “I’ll get back…” part, he does some cool stuff. Again, Donna sounds wonderful singing with Jerry. Garcia’s solo weaves perfectly through Keith, Bobby, and Phil, or is it them who are weaving through Garcia’s solo? Drums end the song, and Jerry begins the NFA chords.
Not Fade Away: Straight up ’77 rocker. Keith SLAMS THE KEYS AS HARD AS HE CAN during the intro. Bobby also teases China Cat Sunflower. The Not Fade Away ends on a soft note, and leads into Goin’ Down the Road
Goin’ Down the Road Feelin’ Bad – A very Chuck Berry like version, with keith heavy in the mix continuing to pound chords with all his might. Ends rambunctiously, with the transition to the half time riff.
Johnny B. Goode – the Gentlemen, and lady, keep the show rocking with a actual Chuck Berry tune. After some 6 string barnburning and screaming, it ends with an eruption of applause.
E: Brokedown Palace – This is my favorite encore of this era. This version might be the slowest I have ever heard this song. Jerry and Donna sing strong harmonies, with Bobby somehow silking his way in between them. Hilariously, I picture Mick and Billy having a fit about how slow they are playing this song. Hopefully they were appeased with the drummers paradise that ended the second set.